Extreme Disappointment

Posted on by

In general, I don’t watch reality weight-loss shows. I used to. Biggest Loser was one of my favorites. I was always in awe of how many pounds the contestants would lose each season, many of them shrinking to half of their starting size. But, ever since I became a dietitian, I view these shows in a much different light. Shows like My Big Fat Revenge, Biggest Loser, and Extreme Weight Loss promote dangerous messages about weight management – namely, that fat people are inherently unhealthy and that the only way to be healthy is to lose copious amounts of weight quickly by drastically restricting one’s calories and exercising like a maniac.

Despite my dislike of these shows, I do (rarely) catch an odd episode from time to time. Many of my clients watch these shows and take what the “experts” say as gospel, so it helps if I am in the know about the latest and greatest gimmicks these shows use, so I can help re-educate my clients.  

Last night, I stumbled across an episode of Extreme Weight Loss that truly disturbed me. In this episode, a 23-year-old woman named Alyssa was the individual who was chosen to undergo a year of restrictive eating and over-exercising courtesy of trainer Chris Powell.  The episode started predictably enough: initial weigh-in tears, a loss of 100+ pounds over the first 3 months (Phase 1), and the inevitable struggles to lose weight during Phase 2 (months 3-6).  

This is where things take a serious turn. After Phase 1, Alyssa found that the weight just wasn’t coming off like it had been before. No matter how much she tried to follow the meal and exercise plan, her weight was at a plateau. So, in order to reach her goal of losing another 60 pounds during Phase 2, she decided to drastically reduce her calories even more, at times eating close to nothing. This resulted in rebound binges and subsequent purging. Alyssa developed an eating disorder (ED).

At this point, the show’s producers should have stopped the program for Alyssa, insisted she get treatment for her ED, and take all of the focus off of her losing weight. Instead, Alyssa had a heartfelt talk with Chris and his wife Heidi (who herself struggled with an ED for eight years), and despite the fact that clearly Alyssa needed help dealing with her ED, they continued to encourage her to lose weight and restrict her calories. She was instructed to eat 1500 calories per day while exercising for at least three hours per day to achieve “healthy” weight loss.

At the very end of the program (and after she had completed the program, losing a total of 200 pounds), Chris offered Alyssa a two-month stay at Shades of Hope, an ED treatment center. While at first she rejected the offer, Alyssa ended up going to the program two weeks later, as it was clear that her eating issues were continuing. Why wasn’t this offer made immediately after Alyssa admitted her ED to Chris? Why did they wait until the end of the year to offer her help?

When someone is struggling with an ED, there should be no talk of trying to lose weight, whether it is in a “healthy way” or not. In a sense, the show itself taught Alyssa how to eat in a disordered (re: restrictive) way, priming her for developing an ED. By letting her continue on in her weight loss program, the show did Alyssa a real disservice and gave the message that EDs are no big deal and are just a “phase” that can be dealt with easily. Unfortunately, EDs are not only extremely damaging (and potentially fatal), but they also often turn out to be a life-long struggle, not something to be glossed over.

These shows are not only doing damage to the contestants, but also doing an enormous amount of damage to their viewers. I am hopeful that one day these shows will run out of steam and stop reinforcing the idea that losing weight and the number on the scale are the end all, be all. Maybe someday shows will promote healthy behavior change, without focusing on the numbers. But, I guess that wouldn’t make for scintillating TV.

Meal Enjoyment and Nutrient Absorption

Posted on by

In nutrition school, I was taught that there were certain nutritional facts that always held true. A calorie is a calorie. If you eat 500 calories less per day for a week, you will lose one pound of body weight. Just because a “healthy” food might not be enjoyable to you or taste good, it is still important to eat it for good health.

Well, there is some interesting evidence that when it comes to nutrition, how much we enjoy our meals may be just as important as what our meals are made of.  In October of 2000, Tufts University Health and Nutrition Letter discussed a study that measured how one’s enjoyment of a meal affected one’s nutrient absorption. In the study, researchers from Thailand and Sweden teamed up to see if cultural preferences for a food would affect the absorption of iron from a meal.

In the first phase of the study, two groups of women, one from Thailand and the other from Sweden, were fed a typical Thai meal. Needless to say the Thai women preferred the taste of the meal more than the Swedish women did. Interestingly, even though all of the meals contained the exact same amount of iron, the Thai women absorbed twice as much iron from the meal than the Swedish women did. In the second phase of the study, the two groups were served a typical Swedish meal with the exact same iron content. In this case, the Swedish women absorbed significantly more iron from the meal than the Thai women did. 

In the second phase of the study, the Thai group and Swedish group were split up into two subgroups. The two Thai subgroups were given an identical Thai meal, but one of the subgroup’s meals was pureed into a mush. Even though both of the meals had the exact same iron content, the women who ate the mushy meal absorbed 70% less iron than the other group. The study was repeated in the Swedish group and the results were similar.

So what does this tell us? Taste and enjoyment matters to nutrient absorption! If you are one of those “nutrition martyrs” who eat foods that you really don’t enjoy just because they are “good for you,” it’s likely that you aren’t absorbing much of the nutrients from those foods. Conversely, even if you are eating a food deemed “unhealthy” by the food authorities, if you are truly enjoying and savoring it, you will be absorbing more nutrients from it.

Now, this isn’t license to only eat “junk.” But, instead of forcing yourself to eat healthy, but not tasty food, how about finding healthier foods that you enjoy? Instead of eating fat-free cheese, which, ahem, tastes like plastic, how about savoring some real sharp cheddar from a Vermont dairy? Instead of munching on low-quality chocolate, how about enjoying a piece of dark chocolate that is full of antioxidants? I am willing to bet that if you start to incorporate more pleasure into your meals, you’ll be happier and healthier.

Fitspiration or Fat-Shaming?

Posted on by

In fat-shaming news, Maria Kang, a 32-year-old fitness fanatic and mother of 3, posted a photo of herself and her three sons (then aged 3 years, 2 years, and 8 months) on Facebook with the caption “What’s Your Excuse?”  In the photo, Kang is wearing only a sports bra and tiny workout shorts, showing off her toned and sleek body.  Clearly, the photo and caption are meant to be “fitspirational” to all of the new moms out there who haven’t yet made losing weight their top priority and to show them that even with 3 kids under the age of 3, you too can have the body of a fit model.  Needless to say, the internet has been ablaze with both positive and negative feedback on the image.

I actually saw this woman on the Today Show this morning, and she was rather unapologetic about the message her photo is sending.  She reiterated the fact over and over that the photo was meant to be inspirational, not a knock against fat people.  That may have been her intention, but honestly, the caption clearly implies judgment against those who “haven’t lost their baby weight yet.”  That perhaps if these overweight women just tried a little harder, they too could bounce a quarter off their abs.

Kang, who is a former personal trainer and beauty queen, clearly has always been in good shape.  Given this fact, it’s not surprising that she was able to “bounce back” to her original shape after her pregnancies.  But the fact is that she is in the minority.  The average woman in the U.S. does not look like Kang and even if she were to put in all of the extraordinary time and effort to achieve Kang’s physique, it is very unlikely that she would be able to maintain it.

So, yes, I do believe that this image is fat-shaming. Instead of sending the message that if you just try hard enough, you can have a hard body after baby, how about telling new moms that they are beautiful and that they should appreciate what their bodies can do for them (e.g. give birth!).  Now that would be inspirational.

My Big Fat Revenge

Posted on by

So, a couple of days ago, I caught wind of a new reality TV show on the Oxygen network called My Big Fat Revenge, a show that appeared to be a hybrid of The Biggest Loser and Punk’d.  Intrigued, I decided to check out the show’s website to learn more about it.  Apparently, the “docu-series” gives overweight women the “opportunity” to not only lose weight through Draconian measures, but also to get retribution against family members, former boyfriends, former classmates,  etc., who had shamed and made these women feel humiliated about their weight in the past.  To do this, the “fat shamers” are “set up on blind dates, auditions, and nightmare jobs to experience what they put their offenders through,” so that the transformed women can teach them a lesson and get an apology.

All I can say is “no.”  What a horrible idea for a show!  Instead of having the women embrace their bodies as-is and then confront their tormenters, this show is condoning the idea that getting thin is the best (and only suitable) revenge.  In fact, by focusing solely on losing the weight, the women are actually validating their attackers’ assertions that they should have been ashamed of their weight.  While the show does assert that fat-shaming is wrong, it essentially undermines this message by saying that unless you lose weight and look thin, you do not deserve respect.

As a television channel that is supposed to be providing inspiring and empowering programming for women, I find all of the above very depressing indeed.

Veggies

Posted on by

I know that many people might not believe it, but sometimes I need to “sneak” vegetables into my diet.  Being a registered dietitian, I am sure this seems odd!  Sometimes I do find myself craving a big, crispy salad or string beans, but there are also many other times when I am not feeling like vegetables, no matter how healthy I know they are. We all know that veggies have so many wonderful vitamins and minerals and are important for overall health. So, what’s a dietitian to do when veggies do not seem so appealing?

Well, in times like these, I try to squeeze veggies into my meals and snacks as much as I can.  At breakfast, I will add spinach or broccoli to my omelet and have it with salsa.  For a post-workout snack, I have been making a green smoothie using baby spinach or kale, almond milk, yogurt, and banana.  It’s amazing how you cannot taste the spinach at all in the smoothie – it tastes just like a banana shake!  With dinner, I try to mix cooked veggies into at least one part of the meal.  If I am having mac and cheese, for example, I will mix in some frozen peas or broccoli florets.  If pizza is for dinner, I will add peppers and onions for toppings.  And of course, veggie-based soups, like zucchini bisque, are an easy way to increase one’s veggie quotient.

Many of my clients struggle with their vegetable intake, and I completely understand this.  However, it is easier to sneak these nutrient-packed superstars than you may think.  Get creative! 

Extreme Measures

Posted on by

The other night, I was watching the show 20/20 on ABC, and I was horrified to see a story they were doing on the “Tongue Patch Diet.”  The procedure entails having a piece of hard plastic mesh temporarily sewn onto one’s tongue, the purpose of which is to inflict pain if the individual tries to eat any solid food.  Apparently, this technique originated in Latin America and is all the rage, with 800 individuals undergoing the procedure at one Venezuelan clinic.  After the patch is put in place, the individual is then put on a strict, 800-calorie-per-day liquid diet or shakes and low-calorie beverages for one month.  In addition, the individual must exercise 45 minutes per day.  After all is said and done, the individual would be expected to lose between 18-20 pounds.

This bizarre intervention made me think back to the absolutely crazy “K-E Diet” aka “Feeding Tube Diet” featured on a number of news shows last year, which involves having a doctor place a nasogastric feeding tube into an individual for 10 days, preventing the person from being able to orally eat anything for that period of time.  The patient carries around a solution in a bag or purse, which delivers 800 calories per day of protein, fats, and water through the nasogastric tube directly into the stomach.  Given that the patient is not taking in any carbohydrates, he or she will be put into a state of ketosis, during which the body burns fat instead of carbohydrate.  In similar fashion to the “Tongue Patch Diet,” the individual can expect to lose up to 20 lbs in only 10 days.

There are many things that disturb me about the above procedures. Both are unrealistic and potentially life-threatening techniques to achieve weight loss.  Obviously, since both are basically very low-calorie diets, the individuals will lose weight quickly.  And as I have spoken about numerous times, using drastic measures to lose weight quickly almost always results in gaining the weight back and then some.  As for the “Feeding Tube Diet,” while being in ketosis might not be harmful in the very short-term, long-term ketosis can result in serious kidney and liver damage.  And since our brain almost exclusively uses glucose (the breakdown of carbohydrate) for energy, going low-carb leads to “brain fog,” where the individual feels groggy, fatigued, unable to concentrate, and irritable.

The “Tongue Patch Diet,” honestly makes me feel queasy. The thought of putting something into one’s body to inflict pain on oneself for eating solid food just seems barbaric.  Why don’t you just hire someone to hit you over the head with a hammer every time you pick up a French fry?!

What I think disturbs me the most about the above is that there are doctors out there who believe these procedures are totally legit and health promoting.  This sends a really hurtful and potentially dangerous message to millions of people who are desperate to lose weight.  If a patient came into my office and mentioned wanting to try out one of these procedures, I would recommend considering the following: Does this seem extreme?  Does he or she feel like this is something that will promote or hinder his or her health?  When the tongue patch/feeding tube comes out, how is he or she going to eat healthfully?  Hopefully after thinking things through, he or she will reconsider these dangerous methods and instead work on healthy, safe, and maintainable nutrition changes.

Five Red Flags

Posted on by

Having worked with hundreds of eating disorder (ED) patients and their families, the question I am most often asked by the patients’ parents is “How did I miss the signs?” EDs by nature are a very secretive disease, and those who suffer with them are pros at hiding them.  Despite this, there are some red flags that might signal that your daughter/son/sister/brother/friend could be struggling with an ED.

1. She is obsessed with watching the Food Network and/or cooking shows, finding recipes online, and with baking and/or cooking for others, but rarely partakes in her own creations.

This is a subtle, but clear sign that something is up.  People with EDs are preoccupied with thoughts about food – where to get it, how to prepare it, and what they can/cannot eat.  Therefore, it is natural that they would turn to TV shows about food, cooking magazines/books, and finding online recipes to fuel this obsession.  Of course there is nothing wrong with doing these things per se, but the key is that a person with an ED rarely, if ever, will eat any of the foods she creates.  Instead, she will bake an elaborate cake and offer it to her family and friends to eat while she has none.  In this way, the individual can vicariously enjoy the food without having to eat any of it.

2. He used to eat dinner with the family every night, but now he always says he ate dinner out or at a friend’s house.

Parents want to be able to trust their son or daughter.  If your child tells you that he already ate, you, like most parents, would believe him. But if your child has always eaten dinner with the family and this new behavior becomes a daily occurrence, then something could be up.

3. She used to love going out to eat and to the movies with her friends.  Now it seems like she finds any excuse to avoid these activities.

As mentioned above, one of the cornerstones of EDs is secrecy.  Most teens with EDs are not open about their disorders with their friends, so it would become pretty clear to her friends that something was wrong if she went out to eat with them and did not order any food.  For most individuals with EDs, simply avoiding these situations is the easiest way to keep their ED under wraps.

4. He used to love a wide variety of food, but lately he seems to only eat a few different foods.

There are plenty of kids who are picky eaters.  The red flag arises in the case of a child that formerly was an omnivore who has now started to cut out certain foods/food groups in an obsessive manner.  Usually this elimination happens in the context of a diet (e.g. “I want to lose some weight to be better at running track,”), so he might begin by limiting carbohydrates and fats, but soon the list of unacceptable foods starts to grow.  This could translate to no longer eating fruit because it has “too many carbs,” eating salad without dressing as it has “too much fat,” etc.  If your child will only eat certain “safe” foods and balks at the idea of increasing food variety, you might have a problem on your hands.

5. She all of a sudden wants to be a vegan, but is unclear about why.

Veganism (the omission of any and all animal products from the diet) is not inherently indicative of an ED.  The question to ask would be why the individual wants to become a vegan.  Is it because, for example, she feels that eating animals and their products is cruel or bad for the environment?  Or could it be another way for her to eliminate foods from a previously varied diet?  By declaring oneself vegan, that means that meat, fish, poultry, eggs, dairy, and a slew of other food groups will be off the table.  In a way, veganism can be used by ED individuals as way to legitimize their restriction.  Of course, this is not always the case, and there are plenty of vegans who are not disordered, but figuring out the motive behind this decision is paramount.

Now, am I saying that if your child exhibits one of these red flags that he/she definitely has an ED?  Of course not.  But I think it is important for parents, siblings, and friends to be aware of these subtle signs and to take action if necessary by talking to a professional such as a doctor, therapist, or dietitian who specializes in EDs.  Forewarned is forearmed.

The Master Cleanse

Posted on by

Is it just me, or does it feel like almost every celebrity out there has been talking about their latest and greatest cleanse?  You know, the one that helped them to lose 20 pounds in only two weeks, gave them abundant amounts of energy, and helped their bodies remove all of those pesky toxins. 

There are numerous cleanses and detox diets out there, but perhaps the most famous one is the Master Cleanse.  Championed by celebrities like Beyonce and Pink, the Master Cleanse is basically a modified juice fast which promises to detoxify the body while also helping you lose weight fast.  For 4-14 days, the individual must abstain from solid food and is only allowed to ingest a drink made with lemon, maple syrup, cayenne pepper, and water.  After the cleanse is over, the individual is instructed to slowly add solid food back into their diet, starting with things like vegetable soup, followed by fruits and vegetables and so on.

As you can probably guess by now, I am not a fan of the Master Cleanse or any cleanse or detox diet, for that matter.  First of all, yes, you will lose weight on a cleanse, but that is mainly just because you are creating a serious calorie deficit.  Most of that weight will likely be water and muscle tissue, not fat tissue, and your metabolism will slow down to a crawl.  Once you stop the cleanse and return to your old eating habits, you will gain the lost weight back and then some! 

Secondly, you will feel completely cruddy while on the cleanse; most people report nausea, headaches, sluggishness, fatigue, dizziness, and numerous gastrointestinal issues (usually diarrhea and/or constipation).  Thirdly, the lemon-maple syrup-cayenne concoction is almost completely devoid of any nutrition, save for the carbohydrates from the maple syrup and the vitamin C from the lemon.  Your body not only needs protein, fat, and carbohydrate to function, but also the myriad vitamins and minerals that a healthy diet provides.

Finally, your body does a perfectly good job of detoxification without the aid of a cleanse.  Your liver, spleen, lungs, and kidneys are already pros at keeping you healthy!

So, skip the cleanse. Your body will thank you.

Cut it Out?!

Posted on by

For as long as I can remember, the “experts” have been telling us to cut down on our sugar and fat intake in order to be healthy.  On the government’s “MyPlate,” the latest version of the healthy food pyramid, there are plate sections for fruits, vegetables, grains, protein, and dairy, but nowhere is there any plate section for sugar or fat.  In fact, if you go to the MyPlate website, the only place you can find sugar is under the “Empty Calories” heading.  And while fats (or oils) are listed under the “Food Groups Overview,” they do not make an appearance on, or anywhere near, the plate.

So, is anyone truly able to cut out both sugar and fat?  Well, it seems like it’s a lot harder than it sounds.  A recently-published review in the journal Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition looked at 53 scientific papers and found that people who follow a diet low in sugar also had a significantly higher percentage of calories coming from fat, and low-fat dieters had a significantly higher percentage of calories coming from sugar.  This phenomenon, which many nutritionists have dubbed the “sugar-fat seesaw,” seems to occur because most sources of sugars, such as fruit, grains, and juices, are low in fat, while most sources of fat, like butter, oils and meat, are low in sugar.

So, what is the average health-conscious person supposed to do about this?  Well, instead of trying to cut out one major nutrient, how about trying a more moderate approach?  How about focusing on eating a healthy, balanced diet that includes all of the nutrients and not branding specific nutrients as either virtuous or evil?  Sugar and fat have a place in our healthy, balanced diets, and they should definitely be represented somewhere on MyPlate.

Super Seeds!

Posted on by

Lately, a lot of my patients have been coming in with questions about seeds: What kind should they eat?  How much?  What are the benefits?  I thought it might be a good idea to come up with a little seed cheat sheet (say that 10 times fast!) to break it down and help my patients figure out what seeds (if any) would be best for them.

Flaxseeds

One of the most popular seeds around these days, flaxseeds are famous for being nutrient powerhouses. They are rich in B vitamins, magnesium, omega-3 fatty acids, fiber, and antioxidants. B vitamins and magnesium are essential for cell metabolism. Omega-3 fatty acids play an important role in reducing inflammation in the body. Flax has both soluble and insoluble fiber, which have been shown to help lower total cholesterol, stabilize blood sugar, and promote intestinal function. Antioxidants help to protect our cells from damaging free radicals that can occur from exposure to certain chemicals, radiation, pollution, and smoking.  

2 tablespoons of ground flaxseed contains 4 grams of fiber, 2.4 grams of the omega-3 fatty acid alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), and 300 milligrams of lignans (an antioxidant).  It’s important to grind flaxseeds into flaxseed meal before eating them to ensure that you will get all of these nutrients. Flaxseed can be added to almost anything to get its benefits – cereal, oatmeal, smoothies, or even into baked goods.

Hemp Seeds

Hemp seeds are very versatile.  They can be eaten raw, sprouted, ground into a meal, made into milk, steeped like a tea, or used in baking.  Like flaxseeds, hemp seeds are a good source of ALA and fiber. They are also one of the few plant sources that are considered a “complete” protein, meaning that it contains all 21 known amino acids (building blocks of protein), including the 9 “essential” ones that cannot be produced by the human body, making it a helpful addition for those who follow a vegetarian or vegan diet.

2 tablespoons of hemp seeds contains 882 milligrams of ALA, 2 grams of fiber, and 5 grams of protein. Hemp seeds can be eaten whole or shelled. Add them to your salad for some extra crunch!

Chia Seeds

While they might be the new seed on the block to many North Americans, chia seeds are native to South America and have been a staple of the Mayan and Aztec diets for centuries.  Like flaxseeds and hemp, chia is a good source of antioxidants.  Due to their high antioxidant content, they have a long shelf life, and they can last nearly 2 years without refrigeration. Chia is an excellent source of fiber, with 10 grams in just 2 tablespoons. It also boasts an impressive amount of calcium (18% of the Daily Recommended Intake), phosphorous, magnesium, and manganese, nutrients that are important for cell metabolism, preventing hypertension, and maintaining a healthy weight. Unlike flaxseeds, chia seeds can be digested whole and do not need to be ground to get their nutrition benefits. Interestingly, chia seeds can be used as an egg replacement: the outer layer of the seeds swells when mixed with liquid, causing it to form a gel. This gel can be used in place of eggs (for those who are vegan) in baked goods. To make the egg replacement, mix 1 tablespoon of chia seeds with 3 tablespoons of water and let sit for 15 minutes.